Introduction: The Two Titans of Super Clone Manufacturing
When it comes to the Rolex Submariner 116610LN super clone, two factory names dominate every forum discussion: Clean Factory and VSF (VS Factory). Both produce what many consider the best 1:1 super clone Submariner on the market today, but they take fundamentally different approaches to achieving that goal.
After spending weeks hands-on with both versions, this comparison breaks down every measurable difference — from case finishing to movement reliability — so you can decide which factory's interpretation deserves a spot in your collection.
Clean Factory vs VSF: The Full Comparison
| Feature | Clean Factory (CF) | VS Factory (VSF) |
|---|---|---|
| Case Material | 904L Stainless Steel - identical brushing to gen | 904L Stainless Steel - slightly softer finish |
| Movement | VR3135 - reliable, good power reserve ~48h | VS3135 - smoother winding, ~70h power reserve |
| Dial Print | Crisp, slightly thicker than gen | Near-perfect, closest to gen on market |
| Crystal | Sapphire with greenish AR (like gen) | Sapphire with colorless AR - slightly clearer |
| Bezel Insert | Platinum-coated numbers, sharp engravings | Better lumed pip, deeper bezel grooves |
| Bezel Action | 60-click, firm with minimal backplay | 60-click, slightly smoother feel |
| Lume | Super Lume - bright, lasts ~6 hours | Super Lume - slightly brighter, lasts ~7 hours |
| Bracelet | 904L, solid end-links, glidelock clasp | 904L, slightly sharper edges, glidelock clasp |
| Rehaut Engraving | Crisp "ROLEXROLEX" aligned to markers | Same quality, very minor alignment variance |
| Weight | ~153g - near identical to gen | ~151g - slightly lighter |
| Water Resistance | Tested to 50m (factory claims 100m) | Tested to 80m (factory claims 100m) |
| Price Range | $480 - $520 | $500 - $550 |
Movement Deep Dive: VR3135 vs VS3135
The movement is where these two factories diverge most significantly. Clean Factory's VR3135 is a proven workhorse — it clones the Rolex calibre 3135 with impressive accuracy, including the genuine balance wheel position. It runs at 28,800 bph and keeps reliable time out of the box, typically within +5 to +10 seconds per day. Service intervals are generally 3-5 years with proper maintenance.
VSF's VS3135, by contrast, represents a newer generation of clone movements. The most touted advantage is its ~70-hour power reserve — noticeably longer than CF's ~48 hours — achieved through a modified barrel and mainspring design. The winding feel is also smoother, with less rotor noise. The trade-off? The VS3135 uses some non-standard parts, making future servicing slightly more specialized.
Verdict: For daily wear reliability, the VR3135 wins on serviceability. For sheer technical achievement and longer power reserve, the VS3135 takes the lead.
Case & Bracelet: Which Feels More Genuine?
Both factories use 904L stainless steel, the same Oystersteel alloy used by modern Rolex. On wrist, the difference is subtle but present. Clean Factory's case has sharper lug transitions and a slightly more rigid feel, while VSF's case has a marginally softer brushing pattern that some argue is closer to genuine.
On the bracelet, Clean Factory has refined their glidelock clasp in recent batches — it now clicks with the same crisp detent as gen. VSF's clasp is excellent but can develop slight vertical play after extended use. Both offer the full 20mm tapering to 16mm at the clasp.
Bezel & Crystal: The Tell-Tale Details
The ceramic bezel insert on both versions is outstanding. Clean Factory's bezel has more precisely engraved numerals with platinum deposition that catches light beautifully. VSF's insert has a slightly deeper groove cut and a better-lumed pearl — but the numbers are marginally less sharp.
The sapphire crystal on VSF has a notably clearer AR coating (anti-reflective), giving the dial a slightly crisper appearance in direct light. Clean Factory's crystal has a greenish tint to the AR that actually more accurately replicates the genuine 116610LN's crystal — a small detail that purists will appreciate.
Which One Should You Buy?
After extensive comparison, here's the honest recommendation:
- Choose Clean Factory if: You want the most accurate overall package, with sharper case finishing, better bezel engraving, and a movement that any watchmaker can service. The CF Submariner 116610LN is the closest you will get to genuine out of the box.
- Choose VSF if: You prioritize the movement experience — longer power reserve, smoother winding — and prefer a slightly clearer crystal. VSF's dial printing is also marginally more accurate.
Where to Buy the Best Super Clone Rolex
At Rotime, we carefully select each piece from trusted factories including both Clean Factory and VSF. Browse our collection of Rolex Daytona 116500LN Super Clone and GMT-Master II Pepsi Super Clone to see the quality firsthand. Every watch is inspected before shipping.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Which movement is more reliable for daily wear, VR3135 or VS3135?
A: For daily reliability, the VR3135 (Clean Factory) is the safer choice. It uses proven design principles and any competent watchmaker can service or replace it. The VS3135 offers better specifications (70h power reserve vs 48h) but uses some proprietary parts that may require specialized service. If you plan to wear it daily for years, go CF; if you value technical performance, go VSF.
Q2: Are Clean Factory and VSF Submariners waterproof out of the box?
A: Both factories test their watches for water resistance. In our experience, VSF tends to have slightly better factory sealing (tested to ~80m), while Clean Factory's units are generally safe for swimming (~50m). We recommend having any super clone watch pressure-tested by a local watchmaker before exposing it to water — regardless of the factory. For peace of mind, our team at Rotime can arrange pre-shipment pressure testing on request.
Q3: How do Clean Factory and VSF 904L steel compare to genuine Rolex Oystersteel?
A: Both factories use genuine 904L stainless steel, the same alloy Rolex uses for their modern watches. The composition is identical: 904L contains more chromium, nickel, and molybdenum than standard 316L steel, giving it superior corrosion resistance and a warmer polish. The only difference is in the surface finishing — Clean Factory's brushing is slightly sharper and closer to gen, while VSF's finish is marginally softer. To the naked eye, both are indistinguishable from a genuine Rolex.
Disclaimer: All watches sold by Rotime are high-quality replica timepieces and are not affiliated with Rolex SA or any other trademark holder. This comparison is for educational and informational purposes only.